Altitude: 29,000 feet and descending; spoilers fully extended, idle thrust
Groundspeed: 563 mph (490 kts)
Souls on board: 189
My blood pressure is falling back to the normal range as the light at the end of the dark cumulonimbus tunnel comes into view. We are about clear (on the east side) of a line of thunderstorms spanning the southeastern quadrant of the Empire. The sun has just cracked the horizon. Hotlanta approach is accepting arrivals without holding... Life is good.
Before we picked our way through this line-up of Thor's children, the co-pilot told the lead flight attendant to batten down the hatches. I woke the passengers up, using my best imitation of the mythological captain's voice, and told them to take their seats and strap in tight. After I put the PA handset back in it's cradle, I remark to the co-pilot, "The passengers are probably freaking out back there because of AF447."
We are flying a new stretch Electric Jet (A321). She is long, lean and gorgeous. I did the pre-flight because the co-pilot, one of my all time favorites, claims to have (maybe) broken his little toe moving furniture for his girlfriend. Of course, I responded with, "yeah... Right!"
Well, we cannot have the co-pilot limping around the aircraft in view of the passengers, so, after attempting to make him feel guilty for his captain having to actually work before the flight, I put my earplugs in and descended the jetway stairs. Once I landed on the ramp, I was glad I had volunteered to pre-flight. The scene before me was visual overload; a new, pristine aircraft being loaded and fueled. She has no brake dust on her main landing gear wheels; they are perfectly white and untarnished. There are no ripples in her belly from hard landings, or streaks of hydraulic fluid that form between wash jobs. She is 40 feet longer, 40,000 pounds heavier, and carries 40 more passengers than the A320. In the world of aircraft, she falls into the beautiful category, or at least I think so...
Down the airways, approaching Memphis, we can see flashes with our eyeballs. They are popping like so many little strobe lights on the horizon. The A321's airborne digital weather radar (the latest and greatest) is showing good definition of the line. I truly wish some of my old Captain's could see this radar; they would be mighty impressed (only with the radar; definitely not the aircraft).
My instinct tells me to turn toward the south thirty degrees and look for a worm hole over Birmingham. I send a quick email to my dispatcher advising him on my plan in case he sees something from his end that I am missing. We have enough fuel to make a minor deviation from flight planned course line. The fingers of my right hand push a few buttons, and we are banking toward the south against the early morning star fields.
Here is where one of the A321's weaknesses becomes apparent, and that would be performance at altitude. The flight crew needs altitude in their tool box to deal with thunderstorms. It helps with visuals (eyeballs on the storm) and choosing a route in the clear, i.e., between storms. When the A321 is heavy, she cannot cruise much above 31,000 feet. Why is this? Well, it basically has the same wing and engines of the A320... Basically, not exactly. But close enough to be an impediment. This causes some of my buddies to have an extreme aversion toward the A321, bordering on visceral.
To me this is analogous to complaining about a beautiful woman not being able to cook. Who cares? Look at the total package. I will guarantee that the Captains (with a capital C) of yesteryear would have been very happy with 31,000 feet and 450 knots true airpeed when faced with a wall of weather in their radial-engine powered Douglas.
West of Birmingham, we can see the towering storms outlined against the pale pink light of the coming sunrise. They are big ones, full of water and veins of electricity, standing shoulder to shoulder between us and KATL. The co-pilot says something like, "This could get interesting."
I take the radar out of Fi-Fi's matrix for a few minutes and turn it into a manual storm prod, poking about in the weather looking for a worm hole to pass through to the other side. Air Traffic Control offers some info about a hole south of Birmingham that a few freighters are passing through. We can actually see that gap on the radar screen. It looks promising...
The flight attendants and pax are strapped in, Fi-Fi is slowed to turbulence penetration speed, and the weather radar is receiving good returns as we enter the tunnel between storms. I reach for the overhead panel and push two buttons to raise the forward ice shields (engine heat).
Two bright blue lights illuminate on the overhead panel. I tell the co-pilot, "Shields are up."
The clouds envelope us with turbulence and ice crystals hissing around the airframe. You can actually hear it. The forward Plexiglas windscreens begin to discharge tiny bolts of static electricity... They look like miniature lightning bolts. The real lightning bolts are on both sides of us; we cannot see them because we are in zero visibility conditions, but each bolt lights up our environment for a micro second with a strobe-light effect.
This is one of my least favorite job requirements; dealing with T-storms. Even though, I do it every spring and summer, year after year, it still makes me nervous. Not so much from fear of an accident, but fear of administrative trouble if we get struck by lightning or run into severe turbulence or hail.
Here is how it would probably go:
Board of inquiry- So, captain (with a little c), tell us again why you chose that particular route through the storms.
Me- Uh, well, I didn't have enough fuel to go around the south end... Uh, south of Baton Rouge.
Board of inquiry- Why did you not have enough fuel?
Me- Because you guys requested that captains stop carrying extra fuel over the flight plan fuel.
Board of inquiry- Well, captain, what about landing and taking on more fuel?
Me- Uh, yeah, I could have done that, I guess. But it costs $20,000 to land and take-off, plus it was night, unfamiliar airport, you know...
Board of inquiry- Yes, but the hail damage on the airframe is going to cost $3,000,000 to repair.
Me- (nervous fidgeting)
Board of inquiry- Do you think you need more training in the use of weather radar?
Me- No sir, I am qualified to teach weather radar classes.
Board of inquiry- OK, that will be all. You are excused for now. You will be hearing from the Chief Pilot's office within a week. For now, you are on administrative leave. Thank you captain.
It makes me sweat just thinking about it.
This airframe is long enough that the flight crew and the cabin crew can feel the flexing of the fuselage in turbulence. It is a bit like being on the end of a pole while something is shaking it. Hard to wordsmith the effect, but it is interesting, none the less. I have a habit of looking at the wing flexing, what little of it I can see, during weather penetrations. I cannot see the wing in this aircraft, only the red nav light on the wing tip. It is moving up and down, though. I guess that will have to do in a stretch Fi-Fi.
The indicated airspeed is varying plus and minus ten knots as we tip toe past the electric dragons on both sides of us. The airframe is flexing, twisting and thumping. I rotate the radar antenna upwards looking for tell tale signs of a hail column about to fall on us. Nothing... In a few more minutes , we will be out of this mess.
The darkness between lightning flashes is turning pink; an automatic stress reducer. Before I can finish thinking about it, we punch through the pink veil into the clear between two cloud layers. The sun is rising at the end of the tunnel. ATC gives us a lower altitude; KATL is close. My fingers push more buttons and The Electric Jet starts descending; I raise the wing spoilers to help her. We are high and fast on the vertical profile. As I tell the wife of my youth, "No problem, baby." In response, she usually rolls her eyes up and shakes her head.
The night is catching up with us. We are getting tired and looking forward to sleeping for a few hours. Tonight, we will do it again... Westbound.
Reminds me of lyrics from one of my favorite songs:
There is a feeling I get when I look to the west...
Stairway to Heaven, Led Zepplin
Life on the Line continues...
45 comments:
'shields are up' - genius. a mate of mine is a airline pilot and when we once flew together as passengers he delighted in clutching the ends of his armrests whiteknuckled and muttering fearfully 'what the f*&ks he doing' to me as every thump and bump of the approach reverberated through the cabin.
Beautiful description. I have ridden jump in a corporate jet through a few summers. Breathtakingly divine when the calm of sunset reveals itself.
I have also seen what a strike can inflict to these birds... Vaporized rivets anyone?
M
Hi Dave
I can't fly. I am a PHOBIC ! But I am completely addicted to your mystically beautiful photos, explanations, descriptions of whatever.... I really have a tremendous respect for people like you who fly these gravity-defying machines. I'm a 60 year old South African lass who will stick to her scooter and Opel Corsa thank you !!! (....and it's hopeless throwing the stats to a Phobic!) I also especially love that you let us in on matters of the heart....
Safe flying Dave and thanks so much for your blog. I couldn't live without it anymore....
Bev
Wow, awesome imagery. As a nervous flyer (that's not true, as a nervous airline passenger, but an overenthusiastic low time PPL student) it actually helps to hear about peoples' "worst weather" experiences in planes... because they're come out the other side, into that stress-relieving pink sky, so it helps to appreciate how strong those paraffin budgies really are. As ever, thanks for continuing to write, Captain.
You have an amazing way with words. I used to fly for American (commuter airline captain (little c)) and can totally relate. Our best altitude was 19,000 and mono radar (only the senior guys had the new stuff). Picking your way through storms at lower altitudes was really tough. What I wouldn't have given for higher, faster and color.
In the meantime I can relive my flights through your words. Now I just build software - no thunderstorms, just bugs.
First to comment! Perfect post in the wake (wake turbulence!) of AF447. Everyone needs a Captain Dave in the left seat.
Dave,
What technique are you using to detect hail on the scope when you use the radar tilt? Any specific shape or coloring I should be looking for?
Just a curious fellow aviator....
Reminds me of a flight I was on from Dallas to Houston. We took off three hours late and flew through this hole and then that hole. We landed in Houston two hours after we took off -- must've gone via New Orleans or something.
But we got there OK.
From us in back, Thanks!
You're the preeminent poet-pilot out there, Captain Dave. Keep it up, you're the best.
-private C172/182 pilot
I keep wondering, how hard can it be to modify and equip black boxes so that they can float. AF447 would have been easier to sort, if we just had them encased in an inflatable ball (for instance) with a water pressure trigger. I am probably shooting in the dark here, I am just an advertising person who loves planes.
It's so much more interesting hearing it from your end than what I see from my end behind the radar where I work as a controller.
I often notice how pilots are much more reluctant to get anywhere near storms in the spring but as the season leads into summer they seem to be more inclined to shoot for holes they wouldn't have a couple months prior.
Once again, I feel at awe with Captain Dave's way with words. Down here in the insect-splatter levels, I can only look up and imagine his views.
Absolutely brillant blog. Keep it coming.
BD
Beautiful post, Captain Dave. Can't wait for the book someday!
Do you have to take additional training to fly the different variants of the A320 family? Seems that there would be a big difference between the A319 and the A321.
Hello mon Capitan!
My wife is on her way back from the other side of the pond today on an A333!!! Her Captain (definitely hoping for a capital C here) has more than enough chances to hit a thunderstorm wall while arriving to CYUL today. Am I fearing for her? No more than usual (still like not to hear that some plane crashed in the morning news following her regular departures for the old continent). This AF447 story, I hope, must have reminded every Captain about the dangers of wheather and if they once forgot about penetration speed, I guess they all revised this material recently and thouroughly. And since you're also sitting in the plane sharing the PAX faith, it's good to read about you guys also stress a bit over wheather in that very front row of the plane.
While playing with that fancy radar of yours, have a little thought for the PAX and Crew of Delta 191, which I guess you somewhat owe them for.
Captain Dave
As always, a very descriptive account of real life on the line. Seeing those weather conditions a lot in the Florida skies, it's always interesting to see a perspective from FL 310 - from the office.
I was with you in that moment looking at the new airplane. And with you in the left seat after your passenger monologue. And with you popping out into the light.
Sweet writing. Thank you!
Addicted to the blog which I found accidentally while looking for AF news a few weeks back. I crane my neck every time we drive by EWR and listen to ATC feeds over the computer...pretty crazy for a 57 year old woman who loves airplanes, travel, and your blog!
MCO Craig here Dave: you know I am an original follower of yours... The spirit of aviation fills your body when you write... your wonderful expressive wording explains what all of us in aviation feels everytime we leave the ground.. I too am married to a wonderful women for 26 years yet she only knows I am like a little kid around aviation, she asks why does this move me so much, how can a cry at an airshow... words always seem to fail me.. but you write about it so well... I'll have to barrow your words next time someone asks me why I love avaition..
thanks.. And God Bless you...
and God Bless Michael Jackson 1958 to 2009
Man, I miss flying in the states... ATC that actually wants to help you (and has the proper tools to do so) and dispatch who can and sometimes wants to help as well... Try doing that going into some crap airport in India or Bangladesh with nothing but your Mk. I eye ball and onboard radar while ATC is trying to vector you in a mountain... Life on the line continues... ;)
After reading your blog for some time now, I have to say your photography skills have increased exponentially :).
Reading your blog has done nothing but increase my interest in aviation. I just completed my very first checkride in aviation a couple weeks ago, with a positive outcome. I appreciate your blog and I hope you continue it!
What a splendid picture! I'd love to see your thunderstorms by twilight.
Surely this plane isn't going to lure you away from the charms of Original Flavour Fifi? FL390 at 31,000 feet?
The 321 sounds a little ungainly, to say the least. My life (as a passenger only) takes me on a lot of 737-400s and the odd A330 / 340 flying from Asia to North America a few times a year.
I can't find the right place to post this, but a long time ago you referred to a young Californian co-pilot full of surf-speak. This comic http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=60#comic made me think of that post.
Dean
Shields are up - Nice Touch. Loving it. Vusa Moyo Pretoria - South Africa
Another great post, Dave.
Just read where NW8 (A333) had an incident over the East China Sea this week. It appears that they lost TAT and all three airspeed indicators unwound. Fortunately the weather was good so flying her the old fashioned way wasn't an issue. NTSB is investigating.
Dave,
Thanks again for a great blog entry. I am an infrequent flyer but prefer to have a window seat, both for the views and because it freaks me out a little to look up the aisle and see the whole airplane flexing in the turbulance. Sometimes discretion is the better part of valor as you can see from the track of my flight from ATL to MCO last week... what's wrong with this picture? http://flightaware.com/live/flight/DAL177/history/20090616/2217Z/KATL/KMCO
Again, thanks for the posting and the reassurance that we will indeed come out OK on the other side!
Tim G in MN
Just to give an indication of how addicted some, including me, are to your blog, I first learned of Michael Jackson's death here in the comments section.
Incredible post. Thanks for sharing your world.
What I'd have given for airborne radar dodging TRWs over New Mexico and Colorado on nighttime "bank runs" in a normally aspirated C-210. Found your really excellent blog while looking for AF447 info. Your calm, understated tone is reminiscent of the late Len Morgan, a Braniff 727 & 747 Captain who wrote for Flying magazine. I read every column Morgan wrote for about 20 years. Great work you do, Captain Dave.
Have seen many sunrises while aloft and am always impressed by their beauty. The sunrise you recently captured and shared is no exception.
Many Thanks for the excellent subject matter and professional delivery!
whiskey papa tango
hi capt, great post i am a airbus 320 capt in India, well you identified the 321 very well. look forward to read your next post
erle pereira
Beautiful writing!
As a passenge, I'm not sure I can fly again until we know what caused AF 447 to fall down. I would have been terrified on this flight!
Thanks for your voice,
penny
Hi Captain Dave,
Been a huge fan of your blog for a while now, and been meaning to write to you. I am a literary agent - I represent writers from many different areas (some celebrities, many adventure / outdoors writers, novelists, etc.) and have long been looking for a writer who can get the passion and joy of flight on the page. You can see more about my company at theagencygroup.com (click on the literary dept link) and contact me through there.
I would love to talk with you and learn if you are interested in writing a book. Just so you know, I was a flight attendant at an earlier point in my life, and am an ongoing aviation nerd of the highest order.
Hope to talk with you, and fly safe,
Caroline Greeven
The Agency Group
1880 Century Park East Suite 711
LA CA 90067
Good'ay Sir,
My name is Martin and I'm an ATPL student, on my way to earning my JAA CPL in Denmark. I've been reading your posts, new and old, for several months now and I'll repeat everyone else's comment that I really enjoy them. In my case, I think it's partly because you sound a lot like my dad, who also flew as a captain on the A320 for many years.
I've grown to wonder what your first steps in aviation were like and would like to know more about how you started, why, where, and so on. I ask this also because you are one of my examples of the kind of pilot I aim to be. I hope you will satisfy my curiosity in your usual lucid, elegant style, which I greatly enjoy.
Kind Regards,
Martin Mitev
P.S. I can also provide my e-mail if you prefer not to post an answer on your blog.
Yep, this is just as good after the fifth reading as it was the first time! So many stories and visuals within the whole, all melded with a wicked sense of humour!
I love thunder-and-lightning storms when I'm safely in a solid, brick house! Not in an aircraft, though.
We once flew into Palma, Mallorca, through a horrendous electrical storm and I was pooping myself. On landing, the pilot made a "welcome" announcement along the lines of, "Well, that was a little exciting at times, but I'm told the weather is expected to improve over the next few hours. Enjoy your holiday and thank you for flying Britannia". Do you guys get special classes in sounding laid back no matter what is going on?
Captain Dave,
Another enlightening post on what aircrews, ATC and "Mother" must deal with every day to keep the skyways safe and moving.
Since you mentioned Atlanta, with your permission I'd like to pass on a link where flight lovers can view either the Atlanta Center or TRACON radars plots as well as listen in and get a better feel of just how much magic happens in the air every day. (time delayed and with FAA consent) http://www.atcmonitor.com/
As for your imagined board of inquiry, does one start with the tower reading out a phone number to call immediately along with your taxi instructions? A 340 aircrew from across the pond received this particular "welcome" today after failing to acknowledge the KBOS controller for several moments after landing today.
Hello Dave
Being a newcomer to your blog (....you've opened up a whole NEW world for me blog-wise), I've just gotta tell you that I access your site almost every day to see if you've added a new-bee to your last post. It's amazing really.....me, a 60-year-old (and a PHOBIC re flying, to boot!) hanging on your every word.....and, umm, feeling more than a tad disappointed if I find you with your feet still on terra firma. By the way, how do folk on your site "attach" photos of themselves ?
All the angels of the Universe go with you and yours Captain Dave (...big C !).
Bev, Cape Town, S.A.
....who-far-prefers-to-ride-a-scooter-than-fly-an-inch-above-the-ground !!! Tho' in my dreams I tend to want to defy gravity somewhat....
I wanna be Dave when I grow up! Problem is, I already grew up. Reading his blog is the next best thing. Thank you very much.
Captain Dave, you should hit up The Agency Group!
Capt Dave: Disturbing Article... your thoughts on the previous 36 episodes of trouble on the 330 & 340 Aircraft.. do you suppose Airbus could be covering something up??
From The Times
July 1, 2009
Airbus could be asked to ground all long-range airliners
Airbus is expected to face calls to ground its worldwide fleet of long-range airliners tomorrow when French accident investigators issue their first account of what caused Air France Flight 447 to crash off Brazil on June 1.
It is believed that the accident bureau will report that stormy weather was a factor but faulty speed data and electronics were the main problem in the disaster that killed 228 people.
The European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) is likely to be asked why it had never taken action to remedy trouble that was well known with the Airbus 330 and 340 series. Nearly 1,000 of the aircraft are flying and until AF447, no passenger had been killed in one.
“EASA has a legal and moral obligation to get to the bottom of this problem now. If there is a defective system and the aircraft is unsafe then it should be grounded,” said James Healy-Pratt of Stewarts Law in London. The firm, which specialises in aviation, is representing the families of 20 of the victims of flight 447.
RELATED LINKS
Child plucked alive from ocean after Airbus crash
Computer bug is main suspect in Airbus crash
Airbus crashes into ocean with 153 on board
Only 11 bodies of the 50 recovered from the Atlantic have been identified. They include Captain Marc Dubois, 58, who is believed to have been resting when his two co-pilots lost control of the aircraft in a storm. The search for bodies has been called off but ships continue to hunt for the black boxes although their locator beacons are assumed to have expired.
Suspicion over the air data systems on the Airbus 330 and 340 series has increased after the disclosure that the aircraft had experienced 36 episodes similar to the one that brought Flight 447 down as it flew from Rio de Janeiro to Paris.
Airbus first reported problems with the speed sensors — known as pitot tubes — in 1994, it emerged this week. The company advised remedies, but no mandatory action was taken.
Last weekend, the US National Transportation Safety Board, began looking into two incidents in which Airbus A330s flying from the US suffered critical episodes apparently similar to that of AF447.
This raises the prospect of a possible US order on modifications to the Airbus.
The first US incident occurred on May 21 when a TAM Airlines flight from Miami to Sao Paulo, Brazil, lost primary speed and altitude information while in cruise flight. The other was on a Northwest Airlines flight, on June 23, from Hong Kong to Tokyo.
Accounts on the internet from the pilots report a desperate struggle to keep the jet in the air.
The fate of Flight 447 would probably have remained an eternal mystery had the aircraft not automatically transmitted data back to the Air France maintenance base.
In the final four minutes, they told a story that was familiar to the airline. Ice particles or water had blocked the three pitot tubes. This upset the air data computers which in turn caused the automatic pilot to disconnect. The pilots would have had to fly manually in near-impossible conditions.
Because you don't have enough to worry about on the flight deck... http://avherald.com/h?article=41c0276a&opt=256
That wasn't your flight was it Dave? I heard on the news that there were many law enforcement types on the flight who helped subdue and handcuff the idiot.
Tim G in MN
jeff- bank checks in a 210. Now that is real flying.
330420KBOS- yeah, sometimes it is a melee on frequency. I am sure you know that, though...
TimG- nope, I heard about it, though... Amazing behaviour.
Tim 12 of 13- no, I do not think Airbus Industries is hiding anything.
My "Dave Low Level Light" in on!
330420KBOS...I once had someone from the front office meet us after a flight saying that the tower just called. My first thought was "WTFinefeatheredfriends did *I* do?" Before I could ask he continued that the tower called to tell him what a great job we did working with them to keep the conga line going inbound. So it's not always bad news.
Post a Comment