
Position: Ten miles northeast of KATL (Atlanta)
Altitude: 15,000 feet... Climbing
Equipment: A321 "stretch" Fi-Fi
Pax-on-board: 183
Airborne...
On the first leg of the day, about ten hours ago, I checked the KATL weather. Between then and our actual departure for KATL, three hours ago, I checked the weather, probably obsessively, at least a dozen times. Three different sources, all huge commercial weather disseminators, agreed that thunderstorms were not in the forecast for Mylanta.
I guess I am imagining those flashes on the horizon. Or, maybe they are swamp gas bubbles popping in the night sky.
My cursing trigger is twitching, still in the OFF position, but loading up the release sear. I resist the urge to look at the fuel gauges. That can wait... I already know we do not have thunderstorm fuel, because I did not upload it, although I knew better.
The email alert flashes; gotta be my dispatcher. I push the print button and the little mini-printer spits out bad news. I ask the co-pilot, a 29 year old kid with not a single grey hair and eyes that can read in the dark without geezer glasses, to read it to me.
Storms building rapidly northwest and southwest of ATL. How much fob?
OK, this is what I get paid for... Don't swell up like a toad and blow a fuse, captain. After a second or two, I chuckle to myself. Of course there are storms at the destination... Every seat full, new aircraft, forecast for clear skies (in the springtime) at Atlanta, and a visual fuel load of which the company flight manual states, "Shows good fuel awareness from the captain." That is new age speak for please do not carry extra fuel unless you deem it absolutely necessary.
Some of the pressure on the cursing trigger relaxes. These new Electric Jets are fabulous aircraft with multiple resources to assist the pilots with this very problem. One of my favorites is a list of airports within fuel range of the missed approach point. A quick look shows at least four airports in range with long runways and big quantities of Jet-A for sale. After considering the wind factor, and geographic location, I select one of the airports for an on-the-fly alternate.
I ask the kid to take a look at it and at the same time shoot an email to my dispatcher requesting him to back me up on the quick-and-dirty alternate.
The plan is to approach KATL from the south, get as close as possible and realistically assess whether we can make a successful approach and landing. We are not going to waste fuel trying an approach with less than a good chance of completion. Missed approaches burn a lot of fuel that can be used getting to the alternate.
The email alert light flashes with a response from dispatch: CAE looks good; if unable to land ATL fob 10.6 proceed to alt of KCAE
Eighty miles south, Atlanta Center says the dreaded words: standby for holding instructions. The fuel loop running in my head computes no more than three turns in holding, but center assures us it should not be a long hold; traffic saturation caused by the storm closed gate to the west. Center allows us to hold at 20,000 feet using 10 mile legs which is a very fuel efficient combo for our current weight. The storms are now clearly visible and they are active with lightning popping in a chain reaction down the line. The worrisome storm is west of the airport; it is a big one allegedly moving northeast. Unfortunately, storm movement depends on fuel-in-tanks. This one will certainly be moving east.
At the sixty mile holding fix, Fi-Fi enters the hold via a direct entry, banking to the right. The co-pilot reports to ATC that we have entered the hold at 20,000 feet. The lightning flashes are getting brighter and more frequent giving the pax a good look at the electric storm as we turn in holding. I brief the flight attendants first, then the pax of my intentions shortly after we enter holding.
The first turn in hold is complete as we cross the fix for the second turn. ATC issues a clearance to the first fix on the downwind leg... Descend to and maintain 8,000 feet. Roger that... Fi-Fi flies a right 360 degree turn back to the fix and departs for the downwind leg. On the intercom, I tell the flight attendants to batten down the hatches and take their seats.
The 321's remarkable multi-scan digital wx radar is another available asset tonight. It does a good job of eliminating ground clutter (radar returns from ground objects) and shows a (mostly) true image of the threat ahead. It is ugly... I am starting to get that re-fueling feeling.
At 15,000 feet, in the descent, we say good-bye to the stars and enter the first of several thin cloud layers prevalent around convection. The clouds transmit the lightning flashes like fiber optics, creating a surrealistic strobe effect in the cockpit. We are in and out of wispy layers until we break out at 10,000 feet with the lights of Atlanta stretching before us as far as we can see. There is a line of storms in our nine o'clock extending towards the airport. West of the airport is the big level 6 storm. The lightning is continuous and spider webbing throughout the interior and exterior of the storm cloud. The belly of that beast is stroking the ground with large bolts, illuminating a large shelf cloud (leading edge of big storms) between the storm and the airport.
This is not good... Shelf clouds are dangerous; on a scale of one to ten, ten being disastrous, shelf clouds are a seven. When I was a green co-pilot on a 737-100 steam jet, one of our most experienced Captains inadvertently flew us into a shelf cloud going into DFW. Our radar was a crude mono-chromatic, barely stabilized unit which was attenuated (overwhelmed by rain) at the time. We could (kind of) see the runway on base leg in heavy rain, lightning, and moderate turbulence. Without warning, we hit a green tinted storm wall, i.e., the lower leading edge of a fast moving thunderstorm. The Captain, to his credit, got us out of there, but I will never forget that incident. It was scary for me and was surely terrifying for the pax/flight attendants.
With Fi-Fi leveling at 8,000 feet a few miles south of the airport, the little red warning light in the back of my head is flashing. The desire to shoot the approach is very, very strong, but I have a creepy feeling of trouble.
I ask the co-pilot, "Whadda you think?" He says, without hesitation, "It doesn't look good." Yeah, he is right. A lot of pax lives are on the line, not to mention a $60,000,000 company asset.
"Tell approach we want to go to Columbia."
The Turn Point...
Against an electrified background of storm clouds, the Electric Jet is ascending back into the safety of the night sky. When I advanced the thrust levers to climb power, Fi-Fi dropped a virtual beacon in her six o'clock, i.e., the turn point. Her nav computers like to see where they have been as they are computing where they are going. It falls into the super-cool category and is one of the many things I love about this aircraft.
I ask the co-pilot to take over the flying duties... I've had enough. He can fly the two re-fueling legs. I notify dispatch that we are on our way to South Carolina. Our long day just got longer.
Life on the Line continues...
37 comments:
My cousin's husband is an ATC at Minneaplois Cenetr and he can't wait for winter. Much easier to deal with snow storms than thunderstorms I guess! Sounds like you made the right choice and that your young cohort has the good sense to follow your lead too...
Keep dodgin'!
Tim G in MN
The tension that you communicate in your post really helps me empathize with you up there on the flight deck.
Thank you!
Question - were the pax / crew grumbling about landing elsewhere, or happy to be safely on terra firma?
I didn't answer the phone.
Couldn't stop reading. {Whew}
Delightful.
By the way, thank you for the picture of Col. Robin Olds, one of the great heroes of the Vietnam War, and the star of the 8th TFW, flying out of Ubon.
KDPK, my home airport! Nice to see you passing by, virtually as it was.
Storms in these parts can be quite vicious this time of year, are you familiar with the saga of Southern Airways Flight 242, in 1977? Every time I read your comments about Fifi's Star Trek-ish weather radar, I think about what Captain Bill McKenzie had to use on that day.
A bad day, I was there as a young CAP cadet, and many years later on the same site as a historian. Interesting coincidence, part of the fuselage came to rest in a part of the Civil War battlefield at New Hope Church known as the "hell hole."
So exciting to read!
Thank you, Captain Dave.
Giulia
Hi, Captain Dave, I have a question regarding weather radar on planes. On a recent Weather Channel blog about the Yazoo MS tornado, the meteorologist said that radar indicated that the tornadic rotation reached a height of 30,000 feet. Would this show up on Fi-Fi's radar and what would it look like?
I found it interesting about the shelf cloud. I have taken some storm spotting classes and if I recall correctly that is where the gust front occurs, so yes that is an area you would not want to be in!
Bravo Zulu Capt Dave!!
Ahhh...the dreaded storms - and ATL gets a lot of them - have flown out of ATL with tornado warnings in the area - that was a fun ride! Thanks for another great read Captain Dave!
Well can't say I've ever had to experience anything like that in my Air Force career flying out in CA. But flying into severe clear air turbulence over the Pacific in between Hawaii and Guam would almost rate up to that. Fly safe and keep up the awesome writing.
Fantastic post Dave, very informative. Very impressed with the features of the FMGC on FiFi
"Don't swell up like a toad and blow a fuse...."
Yho (pronounced 'Yo') Captain Dave!
I love the way you so eloquently articulate those feelings.....with which I so identify !
You don't "do negative" on this blog....but you sure have a way of "doing TRUTH/REALITY" like few folk can.
Gripping writing !!!
May I suggest (most 'respectfully' of course....) that you tell the wife of your wildest dreams that she has absolutely NO need to fear any grammatical glitches that may slip in inadvertently.
What's a grammatical slip worth alongside the lives of your passengers when (O)ne is needing to grapple mathematically with the looming (Under-)Belly of the Beast.
You're THE BEST !
In fact, I'm wondering whether I might have the courage to 'go up' with you sometime (...I'm talking Airbus) but......I doubt it.
No offence meant - this is MY problem entirely.
Here's to You Two for your sound judgement....sez she, raising her glass.
LONG may Life on the Line continue....
Warmly,
Bev
From blue-sky'd Cape Town
A stunning read. I was tense along with you.
I want that weather radar (jealousy ON)!
I just completed a 1,800nm XC in a light plane (4 seats). Eastbound with a 50 kt tailwind was nice. Coming back against a cold front over the Ohio valley and Ozarks with no radar or XM weather on board and the same wind now on the nose - not so much fun.
Thanks you Flight Watch (122.0)
I second the remark from "Gunner". Just finished reading "Fighter Pilot", Robin Olds' bio by his daughter. He fits well with Ripley.
Can I also suggest Gunter Rall (best dogfighter with 302 victories), Steve Pisanos (the Forrest Gump of WW2) and Guy Gibson, VC (of RAF Dambusters fame)?
Fascinating read. Takes guts and good judgement to make that decision. Many have come a cropper to 'press on-itis'. Live to fight another day!
martin scharnke- if pax can see the weather, they usually are thankful to wait a little bit. KCAE is only 20 minutes with the tailwind from ATL. We refueled and were back after the storms had passed.
John the Baptist- yes, I am aware of flight 242. It is one of the classics that pilots used to study in ground school before the new age of learning came on the scene.
Therese- on Fi-Fi's radar it would look like a two dimensional hook, and /or an attenuation warning slash.
D B Cooper- can you imagine the turmoil that a picture of a German fighter pilot would cause on this blog? You should see the mail I get when I write about Lindbergh, who is still reviled in certain segments of our population.
Once again a great post. When people ask in passing what pilots talk about while we are flying along my standard reply is--"We BS about women and blah blah, blah...say, how's the fuel doing?" Or- " Man, the company sure is screwed up bla, blah,blah,you think we got enough gas?"
It's always the fuel isn't it?
Another marvellous entry in a long line of great posts. Thanks a lot!
Whew! I was starting to feel anxious going through those cloud layers and seeing the lightning and storm...then I remembered Captain Dave was on the flight deck and all would be well. But I must admit I was relieved to hear on the intercom that we were off to another airport...
I'll bet you slept well that night, as long as Jet-A fuel dreams didn't intrude!
Love hearing about Fi-Fi's super-cool Star Trekky stuff.
Bev, if you would like to email me, I would be happy to share some ideas with you of my own experiences in turning fear of flying into a love and passion for flight. I understand anxiety very well, first hand, and what seems impossible can be overcome. Life can really open up, a step at a time, and it gets better and better!
jaymarywarden Yes, yes... but can you blame the Company? Think about filling your car up. Then think about filling the plane.
Either way, they better keep it safe. Dispatch and Captain made it work out great in ATL. I hope it stays that way.
The virtual beacons are great. Does it also drop one at the point you wished you'd brought more gas?
You could've always grown 8 more sets of flaps and landed there at PDK -- then I could've bought your dinner.
Common sense is very important!
www.airmailmagazine.com
Couple of questions -
****C****aptain Dave:
1) Was the alternate specified in the original flight plan also in the path of the storm? Is that why you had to come up with a quick and dirty alternate?
2) Why do you print out all the emails in the cockpit? Why not just read them off tyhe display screen (which I assume exists)?
Damn I love this blog. You hit it out of the park with this one.
I like your blog................................
thanks a lot..........................................
So that was you in the A321 I saw on short final from my house in West Columbia the other day!
But all seriousness aside, your story reminds me of all the arguments I had about fuel with dispatchers during my career as a pilot with a major international airline, all of which I won. That was another time, though.
I was just introduced to your blog by another retiree. Enjoying reading it, and keep up the good work!
Great post. Always enjoy reading your blog!
Thank you for being the best reflection of the sweet joy and terror of my life's passion ..flight
Ron- we didn't have an alternate because the forecast didn't call for one. I print the messages because they are usually 2-3 screens long; the mini-printer is fast.
Capn Eddie- thanks for the comments. I still have the capability to win arguments with dispatchers, but I have to choose my battles carefully or I will end up doing the carpet dance in the Chief Pilot's office for hurting someone's self esteem. The old guys who know where all the skeletons are buried are the easiest to deal with...
Just to throw a dispatcher's perspective into it...
It's the person (on either side of the communication) that treats it like it's an argument that is the problem. It's one thing to discuss options and come to agreement on the right plan for the situation. It is another thing to go into the discussion with guns blazing and a chip on your shoulder (this goes for the dispatcher, too).
You're right, though. The more senior the dispatcher, the less likely the "argument". The more experienced I become, the better I plan...and the fewer phone calls I receive. :)
Love the blog, Captain Dave. It's definitely one of my favorites! Maybe, one day, it'll be you I beg for a jumpseat home to DFW. Fly Safe!
Captain Dave un question pour vous. Airline pilots were hitherto regarded with enormous respect for their skills and abilities at taking command in ugly situations when many lives were in their care. They were selected under regimes of extraordinary competition and trained to the highest skill level to deal with technology and to take command in extremis. Do you with your hard earned perspective feel a comment is appropriate at the tension hat now exists between demands for low costs (low pilot pay) and the requirements to have the best in the two front seats or will it take a series of disasters to reinstate appropriate pay levels for pilots
Dave, your post really hit home today. On May 29, we were on approach to Atlanta, storms all around, captain said it would be bumpy. The flight was late, and many people were were concerned about connections.
It was dark and stormy looking...the MD-88 was bouncing through, maybe about 1,000 ft..when we pitched up in climbing turn, engines spooling up...we hit the worst rain I ever saw..the plane felt like it was just hanging there.
After a couple of minutes,we were out of the rain, leveled out, and the captain came on, explaining that a strong rain cell came across the approach, and they called it off. He explained they would try another approach...or would divert to Knoxville for fuel.
We went around, and landed...with applause for the crew.
How often does the average pilot execute missed approaches like this? Was this a close call? It was scary.
Sorry for the long comment...I just found your blog, and the memory of this missed approach/landing is still very fresh. Thanks
Oh Capitaine mon capitaine !
I love your blog. I am french living in Paris and trying to improve my english skills because I have been hired by a british real estate company and need to use english language in my job.
I have been used to reading 'the economist' for that purpose but your blog is a lot much better.
I am totally scared when I travel by plane but i am very fond of learning things about airline business. I have never been able to find the why of this paradox.
Anyway, you are doing a very nice thing writting this blog. Thank you and take care.
Nico.
Post a Comment